Discussion Forum: Thread 129125

 Author: BLUSER_305068 View Messages Posted By BLUSER_305068
 Posted: Mar 13, 2012 17:35
 Subject: Close & Best Price Matches For Wanted List
 Viewed: 130 times
 Topic: Suggestions
 Status:Discarded
Cancel Message
Cancel
Reply to Message
Reply
BrickLink
ID Card

BLUSER_305068 (74)

Location:  USA, New York
Member Since Contact Type Status
Feb 15, 2012 Member Does Not Allow Contact Seller
No Longer RegisteredNo Longer Registered
Store Closed Store: WDM BRICKS
No Longer Registered
There should be an option to get both the "Cheapest Match" and "Close Match"
for your Wanted list.

Cheapest Match Idea: This would compare stores that have all of your wanted
items and meet the minimum quantity needed by total price. It could calculate
the total cost to buy all of those items at the minimum quantity from each store
within the results and compare them in order to provide the cheapest store with
the best overall price. I have seen stores that have all my items charging $600
for the parts and then seeing another store with the same parts charging less
than $150. It would be nice to know which store is the cheapest for my particular
wanted list right off the bat rather than sifting through and filling 100s of
carts with items just to find out manually.


Close Match Idea: For example if you have 3 items set with a minimum quanity
of say 30x, there could be a store that has 30x of two items wanted and only
29x of the third item and because of that the store won't show at all. When
in reality it would be helpful to use that store if there is nothing better just
to minimize the amount of separate orders needed to fulfill your needs. If it
showed close matches it would not only offer more options but would eliminate
the need to keep changing your wanted list quantities trying to find a store
that carries all of your items closest to the quantity you need. So you could
get 29 of that item and know that you only need to add 1x that part in another
order to complete your wanted list.

So you would have the following filters:

Exact Match - The current feature that will only show stores with all your wanted
items that meet the minimum requirement set.

Close Match - This would show stores that have all of your wanted items but a
few of them do not meet the minimum requirement. It could maybe calculate that
at least 90% of the items wanted meet the minimum requirement OR it could calculate
whether all of the items meet at least 80-90% of the minimum requirement. Whichever
produces the best results.

Thanks for reading.
 Author: bb226005 View Messages Posted By bb226005
 Posted: Mar 13, 2012 18:32
 Subject: Re: Close & Best Price Matches For Wanted List
 Viewed: 35 times
 Topic: Suggestions
Cancel Message
Cancel
Reply to Message
Reply
BrickLink
ID Card

bb226005 (90)

Location:  USA, Washington
Member Since Contact Type Status
Nov 12, 2010 Contact Member Seller
No Longer RegisteredNo Longer Registered
Store Closed Store: Stoney's Store
No Longer Registered
In Suggestions, WDM writes:
  There should be an option to get both the "Cheapest Match" and "Close Match"
for your Wanted list.

Cheapest Match Idea: This would compare stores that have all of your wanted
items and meet the minimum quantity needed by total price. It could calculate
the total cost to buy all of those items at the minimum quantity from each store
within the results and compare them in order to provide the cheapest store with
the best overall price. I have seen stores that have all my items charging $600
for the parts and then seeing another store with the same parts charging less
than $150. It would be nice to know which store is the cheapest for my particular
wanted list right off the bat rather than sifting through and filling 100s of
carts with items just to find out manually.

Good idea. I like it!
  

Close Match Idea: For example if you have 3 items set with a minimum quanity
of say 30x, there could be a store that has 30x of two items wanted and only
29x of the third item and because of that the store won't show at all. When
in reality it would be helpful to use that store if there is nothing better just
to minimize the amount of separate orders needed to fulfill your needs. If it
showed close matches it would not only offer more options but would eliminate
the need to keep changing your wanted list quantities trying to find a store
that carries all of your items closest to the quantity you need. So you could
get 29 of that item and know that you only need to add 1x that part in another
order to complete your wanted list.

Why not just make your minimum quantity a few parts lower, to allow more stores
to show?
  
So you would have the following filters:

Exact Match - The current feature that will only show stores with all your wanted
items that meet the minimum requirement set.

Close Match - This would show stores that have all of your wanted items but a
few of them do not meet the minimum requirement. It could maybe calculate that
at least 90% of the items wanted meet the minimum requirement OR it could calculate
whether all of the items meet at least 80-90% of the minimum requirement. Whichever
produces the best results.

Thanks for reading.
 Author: BLUSER_305068 View Messages Posted By BLUSER_305068
 Posted: Mar 15, 2012 12:43
 Subject: Re: Close & Best Price Matches For Wanted List
 Viewed: 52 times
 Topic: Suggestions
Cancel Message
Cancel
Reply to Message
Reply
BrickLink
ID Card

BLUSER_305068 (74)

Location:  USA, New York
Member Since Contact Type Status
Feb 15, 2012 Member Does Not Allow Contact Seller
No Longer RegisteredNo Longer Registered
Store Closed Store: WDM BRICKS
No Longer Registered
Basically because it may not just be one single item that is off by 1x or 2x.
It would be a lot easier if it just showed stores that have a majority of your
items and the quantity available is "close" to the minimum amount you requested.

Of course if it's just one single item it's not too much trouble to go back and
change your quantity but it gets annoying when you're dealing with wanted lists
that have over 300+ lots. Not very easy to keep changing quantities on that
many items.

BEST MATCH or CLOSEST MATCH would be good terms to use for what I'm talking about.


In Suggestions, stonie09 writes:
  In Suggestions, WDM writes:
Why not just make your minimum quantity a few parts lower, to allow more stores
to show?