BrickLink Discussion Forum

Discussion Forum: Suggestions

Redisplay Messages: Compact | Brief | All | Full Show Messages: All | Without Replies

Re: Require 1 Feedback to Post in Forums - zorbanj (822)

[...] Voted No. I'd rather deal with a little spam than not help new users with questions. Bricklink is not the easiest site to use, especially if you're new.
(2 months ago, Mar 16, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Require 1 Feedback to Post in Forums - yorbrick (1185)

[...] Yes. Just report and they quickly vanish if you auto hide cancelled posts. People that feel the need to reply to them are a bigger problem, so they get added to the ignore [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 16, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Require 1 Feedback to Post in Forums - axaday (7303)

[...] This. There are plenty of new buyers who need help before their first sale, but there are MANY, MANY more potential future buyers who come just to ask questions about [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 16, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Require 1 Feedback to Post in Forums - kittybrickz (186)

[...] Im super grateful that I didn't need feedback before posting. There are so many users on here with tremendous encyclopedic knowledge that provide valuable support [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 16, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Require 1 Feedback to Post in Forums - Nubs_Select (3785)

[...] If limited to those with feedback it will turn away many users why are looking for help and if putting a limit on how many days before they can post wouldn’t help as [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 16, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Require 1 Feedback to Post in Forums - yorbrick (1185)

[...] So new users with issues are banned from getting help?
(2 months ago, Mar 16, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Require 1 Feedback to Post in Forums - ErwinNL (622)

[...] I agree somewhat but see an issue where new buyers with questions are blocked by this. A solution might be a captcha (only for your first post) or account activation [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 16, 2024, to Suggestions)

Require 1 Feedback to Post in Forums - BrickDeals (2810)

Spam by new accounts promoting drugs etc seems to be a recurring problem. I suggest that a feedback rating of 1 or higher be required to post in the forums, or new accounts [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 16, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - yorbrick (1185)

[...] They aren't being treated as the same. A store with 90 positives and 10 neutrals has a score of 90 with a percentage praise of 90%. A store with 90 positives and [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Ideal as a payment method - 1001bricks (52411)

[...] As said in PM with FamilyBuild, you CAN define new and other payment methods in Stripe (I tried) - like Alipay or Apple Pay, IDEAL, but as BrickLink only requests/authorize [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Ideal as a payment method - SRvanKlink (1296)

Walking through the Instant Checkout process in your shop brings me as far as 'Credit/Debit via Stripe'. No sign of Ideal of Giropay, I can't see beyond that point [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - zorbanj (822)

[...] It is misleading because the neutrals are treated the same as the negatives and they are not the same. [...] Bad assumption. A buyer should always check the feedback [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Ideal as a payment method - Familybuild (106)

[...] Hi there folks. Its been a while and a bit. But as of now, by the looks of it: additional payment methods seem to be activated within stripe. Please have a look in [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - 1001bricks (52411)

[...] Absolutely. If you wish to leave a really neutral feedback, simply don't leave feedback. But Neutral isn't neutral - it's a blank vote. Still, the whole FB [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - yorbrick (1185)

[...] What is misleading about it? They both have 10 non positive feedback out of 100, so there is the warning from the percentage praise that the buyer should check the feedback. [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - SylvainLS (46)

[...] There’s the “Feedback” tab, next to Shop, Terms, and Splash. That’s exactly where you’re led when you click just below the percentage.
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - zorbanj (822)

[...] Right now it's called "Praise", an odd description even under the current system. [...] Currently, if Store A has 90 positives and 10 neutrals and Store [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Issue, I didn't bring up at the RoundTable - popsicle (6666)

[...] Thanks for participating in the process, nonetheless. [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - yorbrick (1185)

[...] That would be fine, if they wanted to show the percentage praise over the past year or 6 months, or whatever instead of over all time. I'm strongly against old negative [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - steelwoolghandi (2611)

[...] Totally agree with this! ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - zorbanj (822)

[...] Sliding window where *all* feeeback older than the window falls off. Ebay does this. Also, neutral feedbacks dinging the feedback percentage also needs to be done away [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - Brick_Qc (3749)

[...] This issue as been around for years and the users opinions are almost one sided. I remember one debate were a very few sellers were opposed to a change, and they all [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - yorbrick (1185)

[...] And when should positive feedback fall off the percentage calculation? The rating is pointless if it is manipulated to make stores look better than the feedback received [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 12, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Issue, I didn't bring up at the RoundTable - brickerking (1883)

Also, this sounds suspiciously like a borderline seller tool… DENIED! In Suggestions, brickerking writes: [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Issue, I didn't bring up at the RoundTable - brickerking (1883)

[...] Just merge all the variant feedbacks into one: Positive, Negative and Neutral feedbacks should be merged into a new category, “Meh”. Meh is a term from the 90s meaning [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - popsicle (6666)

[...] Indeed. She and perhaps a handful of others here, have both taught and inspired others by example in a very real sense. I'm one of those that gained from such members: [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Issue, I didn't bring up at the RoundTable - popsicle (6666)

[...] Thanks for taking part, and enthusiastic up-vote.
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - kittybrickz (186)

Mad skills! should teach a master class or something!
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - popsicle (6666)

[...] [...] Carol's gotta be up there: (URL)
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - kittybrickz (186)

[...] That neutral super sucks. I know everyone says that neutral is just neutral but if it is then why does it take away from that 100%??? I'm not looking forward to my [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - 1001bricks (52411)

[...] Because as it's the same system since 2000 (>), everyone has the same kind of notation, so it's fair (in the meaning it's the same for all). [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Issue, I didn't bring up at the RoundTable - margaretcm (1033)

Voted YES! LETS GET THIS DONE!!!!
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - margaretcm (1033)

[...] I would very much like to hear an admin’s take on why this hasn’t changed. And disappointing if they see the need, but don’t make the change. I’m on a mission now! [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - zorbanj (822)

[...] Absolutely. Even eBay, a platform openly hostile to sellers, lets feedback fall off after a year. Unfortunately, unless you get the buyer to rescind the feedback you [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - popsicle (6666)

[...] It won't help with your present situation. But if you agree in principle then vote in the affirmative for that principle, and perhaps for any potential 'neutrals' [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - Saitobricks.ca (37)

[...] Half of users are too lazy to leave feedback, five stars may help.🤔 Or they just will still think it’s too hard to leave 5 little stars :D:D:D:D:D
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - Saitobricks.ca (37)

[...] Sounds good! I like your optimism! But I don’t know how much good it will do. But we won’t know unless we try;)
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - 1001bricks (52411)

[...] [...] Apart this, I 100% agree the whole FB posting and counting could be changed. I proposed a 5 stars vote system, like for many on line shops or marketplaces. (URL) [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - Saitobricks.ca (37)

[...] That is exactly what neutral is for, it’s just to say your are not upset, just not happy.
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - margaretcm (1033)

well let’s build up some steam on this! Seems like it pretty much died off a few years back. We need to share the link and comment voted ‘yes’ so we can see where it goes [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - 1001bricks (52411)

[...] [...] Yes, but no? Neutral could've been implemented (by Dan) like a blank (or protest) vote. This hasn't the same meaning than an abstention [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - Saitobricks.ca (37)

[...] I don’t think so, even if you are the creator of the request you can’t see that. :(
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - margaretcm (1033)

Can you see how many votes it has? [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - Saitobricks.ca (37)

[...] Yes! He is wanting the same thing as you, just his had had more time to accumulate more votes.;)
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - margaretcm (1033)

Do I vote YES on this? [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - Saitobricks.ca (37)

[...] If you don’t get it, vote yes anyway:D:D:D:D:D:D:D
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - popsicle (6666)

[...] (URL)
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - Saitobricks.ca (37)

[...] Neutral feedback should be exactly what is says it is, neutral, in other words, NOTHING.
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Feedback. Negative and Neutral impact. - margaretcm (1033)

I’m sure this had been suggested before, but I just received my first neutral feedback (sad day) from a new buyer. I’d be more inclined to be accepting the neutral [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 11, 2024, to Suggestions)

Re: Subscribe to threads and topics - InanimateReason (3460)

Daily digests are a thing. In Suggestions, yorbrick writes: [...]
(2 months ago, Mar 10, 2024, to Suggestions)

Next Page: 5 More | 10 More | 25 More | 50 More | 100 More